Monday, March 27, 2006
Who will save your soul?
Back in early college, I belonged to the campus Christian group for about a year. I was feeling pretty lost and vulnerable at the time, and the group preyed upon that. It ended up being a relatively miserable experience, full of judgment and guilt and manipulation. I finally hightailed it out of there by the beginning of my sophomore year, when the group started going off about saving gay people and masturbators from the err of their ways.I held a lot of resentment and anger towards this group for a long time. I'm over it now, and thankfully have been able to start reclaiming religion, or at least the parts that work for me anyway, out from the hands of the Homophobe Patrol. But why am I telling you this now, you ask? Because, friends and readers, I think my college Christian group might not be finished with me yet. I think they may have plans for me, and I think these plans are being laid out before me through my most treasured of home entertainment fixtures. People, the fellowship has invaded my television.
First, last week I stumbled upon "The Way of the Master." This is Kirk Cameron's post-Growing Pains venture into TV. Because the path to righteousness was paved by Mike Seaver. On the episode I saw, Kirk Cameron and his less famous co-host set out to debunk "myths" about evolution. They did this in several ways. First, they read some stuff out of a science book and laughed at it. Then they held up some dinosaur bones and proclaimed them fake. And finally, the piece de resistance: they rocked it "man on the street" style, grabbing random folks around town and filming them while they bullied them with questions about the science of evolution. The interviewer would pepper each Random Joe with "factual" questions, asking them to explain how and why they believed evolution happened. If ever the interviewee would stumble or hedge in his/her knowledge, uttering a phrase like "I think," "I'm not sure," or "I don't know," the interviewer would echo their words back to them incredulously: "You mean you're telling me that you don't know for sure how we evolved from monkeys? And yet you are willing to believe it as fact?!?" Then the interviewee would be sent off on his/her way in shame. And Kirk Cameron and his co-host would pop back onto the screen to share some info (of the utterly factual variety, of course) about Creation. Which happened. Because Kirk Cameron is kin to no monkey!
The second time the fellowship reached out to me from my television, however, was much more enjoyable. Saturday evening, the husband and I were passed out on the couch with the dog. We love the nightlife; we love to boogie. I was flipping through the channels when I came to some Chicago-based Christian network, hidden way, way up in the double digits with the home shopping channels and the C-SPAN outlet that's always playing random author readings. There was a girl on the screen; she was singing on a stage, in front of an audience and three people seated at a table in a very American-Idol-judge-esque way. The girl was singing something about Jesus and casting her eyes upward earnestly. The three judges watched with rapt attention. I gasped in wonder. "Ohhhhhhhhhhhh. Is this Christian American Idol? IS THIS CHRISTIAN AMERICAN IDOL?"
The girl finished singing, and an icon appeared in the corner of the screen. It was a gold band encircling a picture of a singing woman, and it bore the words: Inspiration Sensation! My husband muttered, "Shit," and gave me a look that was all: is there any way I'm going to get out of watching this? And I was all: have you MET me? And he heaved a weary sigh and started counting the ways his life could have been different had he thought more carefully about that whole "till death do us part" bit.
Let me tell you: "Inspiration Sensation" was Awe. Some. It was just like American Idol except the judges weren't allowed to be mean, the contestants were excessively clothed, and the songs they performed were all about God. One girl named Sheeba sang an Indian-styled "Jesus Loves Me." Another girl sang a song about how the only thing that could make her "white as snow" was the "blood of Jesus." The Ryan Seacrest of the show was this pastor named Dan Willis, who was jacked up like he'd been snorting ritalin between takes and whose catch phrase - which he repeated before and after each contestant and each commercial break and each and every breath - was "You better TELL someone!!" The judges were uber-complimentary, commenting on each contestant's "passion" and "spirit," and only criticizing one girl who dared to make "His Eye is On The Sparrow" too "sultry."
The "Inspiration Sensation" kids were virginal and sincere, the kind of churchy folks that I find harmless and sweet but also, honestly, pretty funny in a "melinda's going to hell for laughing" kind of way. Kirk Cameron, though? Less sweet, less harmless, and funny in a "melinda feels fully justified in gufawing" kind of way. "The Way of the Master" is a perfect example of what was so awful about the Christian group at my college, of why it's incredibly hard for me to label myself a Christian even though I believe, quite strongly, in God. It's mean and superior, full of judgment and scare tactics and finger-pointing. It bullies people who are vulnerable, points a camera at their faces and calls them stupid in the name of a higher power that supposedly loves them.
Somebody needs to call Alan Thicke and Joanna Kerns and tell them to send Mike Seaver to his room without supper, stat. And while they're at it, they could also talk to Carol about that whole drinking and driving thing. Very disappointing.




