Wednesday, June 29, 2005
Speaking in hypotheticals
Last night, the husband and I had an argument about our hypothetical future children. Specifically, our hypothetical future son, and what we might do if said hypothetical son wants to join the (currently blatantly homophobic on an institutional level) Boy Scouts.The husband's position is as follows: Yes, the fact that the Boy Scouts organization discriminates against gay kids is sucky. Yes, we will teach our children not to discriminate. But I was a Boy Scout and it was great. We got to do all kinds of outdoorsy stuff. All my friends were members. My mom was a troop leader. What if all of our hypothetical future son's friends join the Boy Scouts? Do you want him to be excluded? Huh? DO YOU HATE YOUR HYPOTHETICAL SON?
I counter with the following position: Yes, I understand that individual boy scout troops can be great opportunities for boys to make friends, learn outdoorsy skills, and wear stiff uniforms adorned with patches. No, I do not want my hypothetical future son to be a big non-Boy-Scout loser while all of his friends run off on camping trips and whatever the hell else Boy Scouts do. Any hypothetical future son of mine will already have enough odds stacked against him in the social department, what with the excessive amount of nerd genes with which he will assuredly be blessed. HOWEVER. Would I allow a child of mine to join a school club if full rights of membership in said club were offered exclusively to white kids? No. What about an academic quiz team that accepted both girls and boys as members, but only permitted boys to be team leaders? Of course not. So why would I allow my hypothetical future son to join a social club that, regardless of the good intentions of individual troops, at an institutional level teaches children that gay people are not worthy of full membership?
This is a sticky issue. On one hand, I get what my husband is saying. Of course I wouldn't want to deny my child the opportunity to follow his interests, to join clubs with his friends, to participate in activities that meant a lot to my husband when he was growing up. But on the other hand, I want to raise compassionate, open-minded children. How can I teach my children that there is nothing wrong with being gay, and then allow them to join an organization that, in its tenets of membership, insists that being gay is wrong?
But then again, what about changing the system from the inside? Steven Cozza, a straight kid and Eagle Scout, learned about the Boy Scouts' discriminatory position against gays when he was 12 years old. He loved scouting and wanted to stay in the organization, but felt ashamed about the Scouts' institutional homophobia. He began an awareness campaign that started with simple letter-writing and ended up with the formation of Scouting for All, a nonprofit organization that advocates for the Boy Scouts to end their policy of discrimination against gay youth and leaders, an organization of which I am a member. I got interested in the organization a couple of years ago when I saw a documentary film about Cozza. I remember watching and listening to this amazing kid and thinking, "That guy has got to have some incredible parents." What a responsibility, and what a way to change the world -- to raise children with guts like that, and hearts like that. To teach them that religious values have nothing to do with hate, that people are people, that if they ever grow up and vote for war-mongering Texas Republicans for President they will be grounded for life... What a huge and utterly terrifying job.
I don't know. Like I said, it's a sticky issue. Thoughts?






